dotlah! dotlah!
  • Cities
  • Technology
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Science
  • About
Social Links
  • zedreviews.com
  • citi.io
  • aster.cloud
  • liwaiwai.com
  • guzz.co.uk
  • atinatin.com
0 Likes
0 Followers
0 Subscribers
dotlah!
  • Cities
  • Technology
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Science
  • About
  • Technology

Malaysia’s ‘ASEAN Shenzhen’ needs some significant legal reform to take off — here’s how

  • August 25, 2025
Johor Bahru City Night View. Roninjin/Shutterstock
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0

Nuarrual Hilal Md Dahlan, Universiti Utara Malaysia

The Johor–Singapore Special Economic Zone (JS-SEZ) has been hailed as a game changer for ASEAN. Launched in January 2025, this cross-border initiative brings together Malaysia’s land and workforce with Singapore’s capital and connectivity — aiming to be the future hub of trade, talent, and technology.

Expected to tighten relationship toward Southeast Asia’s regionalism, the JS-SEZ is potentially becoming ASEAN’s Shenzhen — China’s Silicon Valley.

But beneath the promise lies a critical challenge: the legal and governance system.

Without a robust, inclusive, and enforceable legal system, the JS-SEZ risks repeating the fate of past mega-projects like Forest City, a multibillion-dollar Malaysia–China property development that promised economic growth but ended up largely underoccupied and criticised for poor planning.

Malaysia’s legal complexity issue

The success of the JS-SEZ won’t just depend on cutting-edge infrastructure or diplomatic finesse. More importantly, it will rely on a clear and effective legal system.

Whether this ambitious plan becomes reality — or just another missed opportunity — will hinge on vigorous enforcement and solid cooperation between Malaysia’s federal and state governments.

The JS-SEZ spans both Singapore and Malaysia — two countries with some different legal, administrative, and land use planning systems. While the ambitious vision includes cross-border mobility, integrated logistics, and harmonised tax rules, Malaysia’s complex regulatory environment remains a major obstacle.

Singapore operates under a unitary system, while Malaysia’s is federal, giving individual states significant planning authority. Unlike Singapore’s streamlined system, Malaysia still faces fragmented land use planning and construction oversight.

Although Malaysia has Development Plans to guide its infrastructure and zoning, these plans are often outdated, incomplete, poorly enforced, or ignored.

To aggravate the issues, legal overlaps and constitutional jurisdiction between federal and state authorities create confusion. The Town and Country Planning Act 1976 (Act 172), the National Land Code (Revised – 2020) (Act 828), the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974 (Act 133), and the Uniform Building By-Laws 1984 contain provisions that not only contradict one another but also grant unwarranted immunity to authorities, thereby creating bureaucratic bottlenecks and fostering unaccountable administration.

Learning from the Forest City

Forest City — once a beacon, a high-profile mega project within JS-SEZ vicinity — offers a cautionary tale. Initially promoted as a smart eco-city for 700,000 residents in Johor, it now houses fewer than 10,000. Many buildings are abandoned, infrastructure is underused, and land reclamation has damaged local marine.

The project’s developer, now facing funding issues, failed to deliver the projected goals. Meanwhile, local communities feel marginalised by the unaffordable housing provided by the project.

Forest City demonstrates how ambitious planning can fall short without robust legal safeguards, effective housing reforms, solid environmental protection, and inclusive planning to achieve social justice.

Delays in getting land and planning approvals, as well as inconsistent law interpretations — such as in cases like Syarikat Bekerjasama-sama Serbaguna Sungai Gelugor, Perbadanan Pengurusan Trellises, and Visamaya Sdn Bhd —
may also keep investors away from Malaysia.

Indonesia’s SEZ experience adds more lessons. The Batam–Bintan–Karimun zone, for instance, suffered from unclear land tenure, overlapping jurisdictions, and poor central-local coordination. Investors faced regulatory uncertainty..

In contrast, Kendal Industrial Park in Central Java, co-developed with Singapore, has succeeded thanks to a centralised legal regime and streamlined approvals.

How to fix the problems

To avoid repeating past mistakes, five urgent reforms for JS-SEZ are needed:

1. Enact a dedicated JS-SEZ land development act

This law must integrate and coordinate planning, land, transportation, environmental, taxation, building, and investment regulations across the federal and state governments. With six local authorities and 11 priority sectors involved, overlapping jurisdictions could lead to duplication, delays, and confusion.

2. Create a statutory master plan

Johor and Singapore should initiate a special development and master plan that governs land use planning covering infrastructure, housing, logistics, sustainability, and public services. Without legal weight, such plans risk being shelved. The blueprint must be strategic, implementable, and regularly reviewed to maintain its effectiveness and relevance over time.

3. Empower technical agencies

Public works, environment, geo-science and mineral, and irrigation departments, as well as other relevant technical agencies, should move beyond advisory roles to decision-making authority in land use planning. Their approvals should be premised on sound technical, safety, and environmental grounds.

These technical agencies should also be legally responsible for providing accurate, up-to-date big data and analytics for every district in Malaysia, including challenges and measures. Outdated guidelines must be replaced with real-time insights, and artificial intelligence should be adopted to enhance decision-making and service delivery.

4. Community inclusion

Planning must be people-centered. Zoning should strike a balance between investor interests, housing and property affordability, green spaces along with public amenities, interest, and welfare. Community consultation should go beyond symbolism and become a legal requirement, with feedback influencing decisions.

Another pressing issue is rampant land speculation with property prices adjacent to the RTS transit stations spiking to more than MYR2,000 per square foot (approximately US$470).

Such rapid increases price out residents from the housing market. Legal means like land price controls, mandatory quotas for affordable housing, and the application of reversionary rights could be used to ensure inclusivity and equitable urban development.

5. Energy transparency

The JS-SEZ’s long-term success also depends on clean, stable energy. Data centres, for example, require reliable high-capacity power.

Energy infrastructure will also determine the viability of JS-SEZ. Industries, especially data centres, need stable, clean power.

While solar and hydrogen are promising, they may not meet short-term industrial needs. A shared nuclear energy project between Malaysia and Singapore could offer a sustainable solution by modelling after the Krško plant in Slovenia and Croatia.

However, such a project must be grounded in robust laws, meaningful public participation, and rigorous safety and security standards.

We must not build another Forest City. We must create a future that works for all —legally, sustainably, and inclusively.The Conversation

Nuarrual Hilal Md Dahlan, School of Law, Universiti Utara Malaysia

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article ( https://theconversation.com/malaysias-asean-shenzhen-needs-some-significant-legal-reform-to-take-off-heres-how-261387 ).

Total
0
Shares
Share
Tweet
Share
Share
Related Topics
  • Indonesia
  • JS-SEZ
  • Malaysia
  • Singapore
  • Special Economic Zones
dotlah.com

Previous Article
French Fries
  • Gears

Air Fryer: The One Cooking Appliance to Rule Them All – Best All-Around Picks in 2025

  • August 22, 2025
View Post
Next Article
  • Gears
  • Technology

Meet Samsung Galaxy Tab S11 Series: Packing Everything You Expect From a Premium Tablet

  • September 4, 2025
View Post
You May Also Like
View Post
  • Gears
  • Technology

Meet Samsung Galaxy Tab S11 Series: Packing Everything You Expect From a Premium Tablet

  • Dean Marc
  • September 4, 2025
View Post
  • Gears
  • Technology

Samsung Electronics Debuts Odyssey G7 Monitors, Showcasing Top Games on Its Displays at Gamescom 2025

  • Dean Marc
  • August 20, 2025
View Post
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Technology

Thoughts on America’s AI Action Plan

  • Dean Marc
  • July 24, 2025
View Post
  • Technology

ESWIN Computing launches the EBC77 Series Single Board Computer with Ubuntu

  • dotlah.com
  • July 17, 2025
View Post
  • Gears
  • Technology

Samsung Galaxy Z Fold7: Raising the Bar for Smartphones

  • Dean Marc
  • July 9, 2025
View Post
  • Cities
  • Technology

Meralco PowerGen’s PacificLight starts up 100 MW fast-response plant in Singapore

  • dotlah.com
  • June 20, 2025
View Post
  • Technology

Apple services deliver powerful features and intelligent updates to users this autumn

  • Dean Marc
  • June 12, 2025
View Post
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Machine Learning
  • Technology

Apple supercharges its tools and technologies for developers to foster creativity, innovation, and design

  • Dean Marc
  • June 11, 2025


Trending
  • 1
    • Cities
    • People
    What Do I Do If I Get Into A Car Accident In Canada?
    • June 13, 2020
  • social-media-heart-karsten-winegeart-60GsdOMRFGc-unsplash 2
    • People
    • Technology
    How Social Media Can Help Boost Your Optimism
    • April 9, 2022
  • 3
    • Lah!
    DBS Rolls Out Branch Transformation To Boost Convenience And Accessibility For Customers
    • November 17, 2020
  • 4
    • Lah!
    The Maritime And Port Authority Of Singapore Clinches Innovation Excellence Award For Driving Maritime Transformation
    • October 9, 2019
  • 5
    • Cities
    • Lah!
    CapitaLand And CDL To Launch CanningHill Piers, Tallest Residential Development Along The Singapore River
    • November 3, 2021
  • Portrait of Rosalynn Carter, 1993 6
    • People
    Former First Lady Rosalynn Carter Passes Away at Age 96
    • November 19, 2023
  • 7
    • Lah!
    Singapore And Estonia Reaffirm Friendly Defence Relations
    • July 13, 2021
  • 8
    • Cities
    • Lah!
    Ascott Is World’s First Hospitality Company To Offer Global Telehealth, Telecounselling And Travel Security Advisory To Guests
    • June 1, 2021
  • 9
    • Lah!
    • Science
    • Technology
    Increasing The Accuracy Of Mosquito Vector Surveillance
    • August 24, 2021
  • 10
    • Technology
    NUS To Boost Future-Readiness Of Students And Graduates With New Digital Skills Marketplace And Networking Platform
    • January 31, 2022
  • 11
    • Cities
    MAS Tells Financial Institutions To Adopt Safe Distancing Measures
    • March 25, 2020
  • hiv aids 12
    • People
    • World Events
    Battles won – and lost – against AIDS hold valuable lessons for managing COVID-19
    • December 2, 2020
Trending
  • 1
    Singapore’s national identity excludes those who don’t look like a ‘regular family’
    • October 9, 2025
  • Smart Watch 2
    Best Smartwatches, Your Gateway to Health Monitoring and Everyday Use
    • October 5, 2025
  • Cooking pots and pans 3
    Best Pots and Pans 2025: All-Season, All-Purpose Picks for Every Kitchen
    • September 23, 2025
  • 4
    Politicians love comparing NZ’s economy to Singapore or Ireland – but it’s simplistic and misleading
    • September 21, 2025
  • Kitchen Knives - Best All-Around Picks in 2025 5
    Kitchen Knives : The Surgeons of Cooking – Best All-Around Picks in 2025
    • September 15, 2025
  • 6
    Apple unveils iPhone 17 Pro and iPhone 17 Pro Max, the most powerful and advanced Pro models ever
    • September 9, 2025
  • 7
    Apple debuts iPhone 17
    • September 9, 2025
  • Fruits and vegetables for cooking. For food processors. 8
    Food Processor: The Swiss Army Knife of the Kitchen – Best All-Around Picks in 2025
    • September 8, 2025
  • 9
    Meet Samsung Galaxy Tab S11 Series: Packing Everything You Expect From a Premium Tablet
    • September 4, 2025
  • 10
    Malaysia’s ‘ASEAN Shenzhen’ needs some significant legal reform to take off — here’s how
    • August 25, 2025
Social Links
dotlah! dotlah!
  • Cities
  • Technology
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Science
  • About
Connecting Dots Across Asia's Tech and Urban Landscape

Input your search keywords and press Enter.