dotlah! dotlah!
  • Cities
  • Technology
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Science
  • About
Social Links
  • zedreviews.com
  • citi.io
  • aster.cloud
  • liwaiwai.com
  • guzz.co.uk
  • atinatin.com
0 Likes
0 Followers
0 Subscribers
dotlah!
  • Cities
  • Technology
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Science
  • About
  • Cities

Affordable Housing Lessons From Sydney, Hong Kong And Singapore: 3 Keys To Getting The Policy Mix Right

  • October 9, 2019
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0

Affordable housing is a critical problem for Australia’s biggest housing markets. Five Australian cities are in the top 25 with “severely unaffordable” housing in a 2019 Demographia survey of 91 major metropolitan markets. Sydney was ranked the third least affordable of the 91.

With more than 80% of Singaporeans living in state-provided housing, the city rates well for affordability compared to Sydney, where the figure is just 5.5%. Bill Roque/Shutterstock

The average age of first-time buyers in Sydney has reached 38. And, on average, tenants spend more than 30% of their income on rent. Those who entered the Sydney market 10-15 years ago are more likely to find their housing affordable.

Cities with housing affordability issues have introduced various policy packages in response. This article compares the policies of Singapore, where housing is relatively affordable, Hong Kong (the world’s least affordable private housing market) and Sydney. Our review shows a need for coherent and coordinated housing policies – a synergistic approach that multiplies the impacts of individual policies.

Housing has direct impacts on people’s well-being. A housing market that works well may also enhance the economic productivity of a city. If not handled properly, housing affordability issues may trigger economic and political crises.

Our review covers several aspects.

A balance of renters and owners

First, an affordable housing system needs to be about both the rental and ownership sectors.

In Singapore, public housing provided by the Housing and Development Board makes up 73% of Singapore’s total housing stock, which includes public rental and subsidised ownership. HDB flats house over 80% of Singapore’s resident population, with about 90% owning their homes. The average waiting time to get public housing is three to four years.

Public housing is also important, although to a lesser extent, in Hong Kong. In this city, 44.7% of the population live in public housing. The average waiting time is three to five years, depending on household type.

In both cities, subsidised rental and subsidised ownership are an integral part of the public housing system, which aims to improve housing affordability.

Sydney takes a very different approach. Social rental housing provides only 5.56% of housing and covers only low-income households in “priority need”. The average waiting time to get into social housing is five to ten years.

Although there are other policy measures to support home buying and rental (such as the National Rental Affordability Scheme), these are not integrated with the public housing system in Sydney. Rather, the goal of these policies is to support the private housing market.

It’s not just about housing supply

Second, housing affordability needs to be backed up by demand-side policies – i.e. policies to help tenants and owners to develop financial capacity.

Despite its heavy state intervention, Singapore’s public housing stresses the responsibility of individuals. The Housing Provident Fund is a form of forced savings for housing, retirement, health and education, among other things. It is integrated with the pension system to enhance the efficiency of savings.

Forced savings are not available in Hong Kong and Sydney for housing purposes. Since 2017 first home buyers in Australia have been able to draw on their voluntary superannuation contributions for a deposit.

Work-life balance matters

Third, action on housing affordability needs to take employment and its location into account.

Ultimately, the reason people find it hard to afford housing in certain locations is because they need to achieve a work-life balance. Both Hong Kong and Singapore have developed extensive public transport systems. These offer affordable options for people to travel efficiently to and from work.

In Hong Kong, the average daily commuting time by public transport is 73 minutes. Some 21% of the residents have to travel for more than two hours a day. In Singapore, average commuting time is 84 minutes, with 25% exceeding two hours.

In Sydney, the average time is 82 minutes, but 31% take more than two hours. This means a significantly larger proportion of Sydney residents spend more time on public transport. Among the worst-affected are white-collar workers from the city’s west and southwest.

Lessons from the 3 cities

So, what we can learn from these cities’ experiences with housing affordability?

Cities take very different approaches to these issues. Each approach has its own merits and issues.

A key argument against public housing has been that it might give the tenants less incentive to save for housing. It might also not be popular with mainstream voters because of the cost to taxpayers.

Singapore’s approach seems to be a midway solution. The government plays a bigger role in providing housing, but does not waive individual responsibilities. Providing public housing and at the same time demanding individuals and employers contribute can send a strong signal: people are encouraged to join the labour force.

So far, Singapore faces the least housing affordability issues. Hong Kong and Sydney are much more liberal in their approaches to housing.

In Sydney, only the poorest benefit from the public housing system. The younger generation is struggling to get on the housing ladder.

In Hong Kong, people are forced to buy housing in the commercial market if their income is even just above the eligibility line for public housing. The severe unaffordability of private housing in Hong Kong, even for young professionals, brews social discontent.

Combining these three perspectives, Sydney’s housing, savings and public transport systems are far from well synergised to offer a competitive package of affordable housing. The 30-minute city plan prepared by the Greater Sydney Commission might improve the situation. However, similar to Hong Kong, current policies are weak in building the capacity of young people to own homes.

The Conversation

Youqing Fan, Lecturer, Western Sydney University; Bingqin Li, Associate Professor and Director of Chinese Social Policy Program, UNSW, and Chyi Lin Lee, Associate Professor of Property, UNSW

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Total
0
Shares
Share
Tweet
Share
Share
Related Topics
  • Hong Kong
  • Housing
  • Rentals
  • Singapore
  • Sydney
majulah

Previous Article
  • Lah!

The Maritime And Port Authority Of Singapore Clinches Innovation Excellence Award For Driving Maritime Transformation

  • October 9, 2019
View Post
Next Article
  • Science

Singapore Scientists Simplify Lithium-Sulfur Battery Production to Meet Future Energy Storage Needs

  • October 10, 2019
View Post
You May Also Like
View Post
  • Cities
  • Research

Mathematicians uncover the logic behind how people walk in crowds

  • dotlah.com
  • April 3, 2025
“Toyota Woven City,” a Test Course for Mobility, Completes Phase 1 Construction and Prepares for Launch
View Post
  • Cities
  • Technology

“Toyota Woven City,” a Test Course for Mobility, Completes Phase 1 Construction and Prepares for Launch

  • John Francis
  • January 6, 2025
View Post
  • Cities

Popes were once confined to Rome. Now they travel the world – and Francis’ current journey is particularly significant

  • dotlah.com
  • September 13, 2024
Singapore
View Post
  • Cities
  • Economy

South Africa’s new pension rules: Australia, Chile and Singapore show how personal savings can grow the economy

  • dotlah.com
  • August 30, 2024
Singapore
View Post
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cities
  • Technology

These 5 cities are making innovative use of generative AI

  • dotlah.com
  • July 29, 2024
dotlah-singapore-kharl-anthony-paica-Btf-M-Hu8Xw-unsplash
View Post
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cities
  • Technology

These 4 cities are making innovative use of generative AI

  • dotlah.com
  • May 16, 2024
Fashion. Fashion walk.
View Post
  • Cities
  • Features

French Chic. An intro to Parisian Fashion.

  • John Francis
  • May 10, 2024
dotlah-sentosa-joshua-tsu-4sl0QBBHRRA-unsplash
View Post
  • Cities
  • Lah!

Discover Sentosa anew through partnership of iconic brands

  • dotlah.com
  • May 10, 2024


Trending
  • power-lines-pexels-photo-3791191 1
    • Cities
    Everything You Need To Know About Power Lines In One Place
    • June 19, 2021
  • 2
    • Business
    • Politics
    Which Countries Achieved Economic Growth? And Why Does It Matter?
    • February 17, 2020
  • Thunderobot 3
    • Technology
    THUNDEROBOT Debuts at CES 2025 to Unleash the Infinite Potential of Esports Gear by Powerful Esports Momentum
    • January 8, 2025
  • 4
    • Economy
    • People
    Why Has Youth Unemployment Risen So Much In China?
    • May 31, 2023
  • 5
    • Lah!
    Playing With Fire: The Economics And Network Of Fire And Haze
    • September 16, 2019
  • car-street-london-1932153_1280 6
    • Cities
    Beginner Tips For City Driving
    • February 22, 2021
  • goswifties_from-stockholm-to-lisbon_20240523_wm 7
    • Featured
    From The Heart of Stockholm To Welcoming City Of Seven Hills
    • May 24, 2024
  • martin-luther-king-jr-unseen-histories-G2vxuMlATxA-unsplash 8
    • Books
    • People
    Martin Luther King Jr: 5 Books To Read To Understand Him Better
    • January 16, 2023
  • 9
    • Lah!
    • Technology
    Asia Tech x Singapore Unveils Exciting Speaker Line-Up That Explores The Intersection Of Technology, Society & The Digital Economy
    • July 7, 2021
  • 10
    • Science
    Singapore Scientists Develop Advanced Human Liver Organoids
    • July 17, 2020
  • 11
    • Lah!
    • Society
    DBS Rolls Out Digital Solutions To Give Businesses “Contact-free” Banking Options For Greater Peace Of Mind During Covid-19
    • February 29, 2020
  • 12
    • Science
    Black Holes Are Simpler Than Forests And Science Has Its Limits
    • August 23, 2019
Trending
  • 1
    The Summer Adventures : Hiking and Nature Walks Essentials
    • June 3, 2025
  • 2
    Trump’s global trade plans are in disarray, after a US court ruling on ‘Liberation Day’ tariffs
    • May 29, 2025
  • 3
    315,000 Singaporeans have used new career and skills planning tool by SkillsFuture Singapore
    • May 23, 2025
  • college-of-cardinals-2025 4
    The Definitive Who’s Who of the 2025 Papal Conclave
    • May 8, 2025
  • conclave-poster-black-smoke 5
    The World Is Revalidating Itself
    • May 7, 2025
  • oracle-ibm 6
    IBM and Oracle Expand Partnership to Advance Agentic AI and Hybrid Cloud
    • May 6, 2025
  • 7
    Conclave: How A New Pope Is Chosen
    • April 25, 2025
  • 8
    Canonical Releases Ubuntu 25.04 Plucky Puffin
    • April 17, 2025
  • 9
    Mathematicians uncover the logic behind how people walk in crowds
    • April 3, 2025
  • 10
    Tokyo Electron and IBM Renew Collaboration for Advanced Semiconductor Technology
    • April 2, 2025
Social Links
dotlah! dotlah!
  • Cities
  • Technology
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Science
  • About
Connecting Dots Across Asia's Tech and Urban Landscape

Input your search keywords and press Enter.